As voted on by Grinders staff
| Season | MVP | OPOY | DPOY | Most Improved | “Justin Gerardi” Man of The Year | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025.3 | Chaz Hooks | Jimmy Zeitz | Paul Palombo | Jonathan Urbaniak | Kellen Owen | Eric Boerdner |
| 2025.1 | Curtis Masich | Tommy Hughes | Mike Malicki | Paul Johnson | Chris Cole | |
| 2024.3 | Wayne Haynes | Peyton Urbaniak |